Still one of a kind’ – Man Utd urged to bring ‘higher standard’ Paul Pogba back for third spell despite World Cup winner carrying ‘baggage’ after doping ban
Still One of a Kind’ – Man Utd Urged to Bring ‘Higher Standard’ Paul Pogba Back for Third Spell Despite World Cup Winner Carrying ‘Baggage’ After Doping Ban
Manchester United fans and football pundits alike remain divided over the prospect of Paul Pogba’s return to Old Trafford. The French midfielder, once considered a generational talent, left United under a cloud twice before. However, some voices argue that his “higher standard” of play could still benefit the Red Devils despite the “baggage” he carries, especially following his doping ban.
With United still struggling for midfield dominance, could Pogba’s return for a third spell be a game-changer? Let’s break down the possibilities, challenges, and potential benefits of his return.
Paul Pogba: Still One of a Kind or More Trouble Than He’s Worth?
Paul Pogba’s career has been anything but ordinary. A player with immense talent, he has shown moments of brilliance that few can replicate. However, his inconsistency, injury struggles, and now a doping ban have raised serious concerns.
Would Manchester United be wise to take the risk again? Some believe that despite his setbacks, Pogba’s return could elevate the team, providing much-needed creativity and leadership in the midfield. Others, however, worry that history could repeat itself.
Why Man Utd Might Consider Bringing Pogba Back
1. A Midfield Maestro with Unmatched Quality
Despite the controversies, few can deny Pogba’s ability. His passing range, vision, and physical presence in midfield have made him a world-class player when at his best.
United have struggled for consistency in midfield, relying on players like Casemiro and Bruno Fernandes. Bringing back Pogba could add depth and experience to an area where the team has been lacking.
2. Experience and a Winning Mentality
Paul Pogba is a World Cup winner with France, an achievement that speaks volumes about his quality. His experience in major tournaments and high-pressure matches could benefit a United squad still learning to handle the biggest stages.
Even during his turbulent times at Old Trafford, Pogba produced moments of brilliance, such as his stunning performance in the 2021 Europa League campaign. If properly managed, he could still be a valuable asset.
3. Redemption Story & Motivation
Following his doping ban, Pogba may have a strong desire to prove himself again. A motivated Pogba, eager to silence his critics, could be a dangerous weapon in the Premier League.
The Risks of Bringing Pogba Back to Manchester United
1. Injury and Fitness Concerns
Pogba’s injury record has been a significant concern throughout his career. Since leaving Manchester United for Juventus, he has struggled to maintain peak fitness, spending more time on the sidelines than on the pitch.
After serving a doping ban, questions will arise about his ability to return to full match sharpness. United need reliability in midfield, and Pogba’s track record makes him a gamble.
2. Dressing Room Disruptions & Baggage
Paul Pogba has been known for his outspoken nature and off-field distractions. His relationship with Jose Mourinho famously deteriorated, leading to dressing-room tensions.
United have been attempting to rebuild a strong, disciplined squad under Erik ten Hag. Bringing Pogba back could risk disrupting team chemistry, especially if past issues resurface.
3. Financial Implications
A player of Pogba’s caliber does not come cheap. Given United’s financial strategy, would they be willing to invest in a player who previously left on a free transfer? Juventus signed him for free, only for his time there to be plagued with injuries and now a ban.
Would United be making the same mistake twice?
What Football Experts and Fans Are Saying
The football world is divided on whether Pogba should return. Some pundits believe that despite his setbacks, his ability remains unmatched and that United should take the gamble. Others argue that his baggage, both on and off the field, makes him a risk not worth taking.
Gary Neville’s Take
Former United captain Gary Neville has previously criticized Pogba’s inconsistency, stating that while he is immensely talented, he hasn’t justified his price tag.
Roy Keane’s Opinion
Keane, never one to hold back, has questioned Pogba’s commitment and leadership, arguing that United need players who can be relied upon week in, week out.
Fans’ Reactions on Social Media
- “Pogba at his best is unplayable. If he comes back with the right attitude, he could be exactly what we need.” – @RedDevilFan
- “Too much drama, too much baggage. We need stability, not another Pogba saga.” – @UnitedForever
Would Pogba Fit into Ten Hag’s System?
Manchester United under Erik ten Hag have emphasized discipline, work rate, and structured play. The Dutchman prefers midfielders who can maintain tactical discipline while contributing defensively and offensively.
Pogba, known for his attacking flair but sometimes criticized for lack of defensive effort, might struggle to fit seamlessly into Ten Hag’s demanding system.
However, if United could find a way to maximize his strengths while minimizing his weaknesses, a return could still be beneficial.
Conclusion: Should Manchester United Take the Risk?
Paul Pogba is undoubtedly a unique talent, but his return to Manchester United comes with significant risks. While his ability could strengthen United’s midfield, his history of injuries, off-field distractions, and inconsistent performances make this a tough decision.
Would Pogba bring a “higher standard” back to Old Trafford, or would his “baggage” outweigh his talent? Manchester United must carefully weigh their options before making a move that could define the club’s future.
FAQ Section
1. Why did Paul Pogba leave Manchester United the first two times?
Pogba left United first in 2012 due to a lack of playing time under Sir Alex Ferguson. He returned in 2016 for a then-world-record fee but departed again in 2022 after failing to agree on a new contract.
2. What is Paul Pogba’s current status after his doping ban?
Pogba has been suspended due to a doping violation and is awaiting further legal proceedings. His future in football remains uncertain.
3. Has Erik ten Hag commented on a potential Pogba return?
As of now, Ten Hag has not publicly addressed any rumors regarding Pogba’s return to Manchester United.
4. Would Pogba’s return impact Bruno Fernandes and Casemiro?
If Pogba were to return, it would add another creative midfielder to the squad. Whether he would start regularly or play a rotational role remains to be seen.
5. What are Manchester United fans saying about Pogba’s possible return?
Opinions are mixed. Some fans believe Pogba could still contribute, while others think the club should move on and invest in younger, more reliable talents.
Quick Wiki Data Table: Paul Pogba’s Career
| Attribute | Details |
|---|---|
| Full Name | Paul Labile Pogba |
| Date of Birth | March 15, 1993 |
| Nationality | French |
| Position | Central Midfielder |
| Current Club | Juventus (suspended) |
| Former Clubs | Manchester United, Juventus |
| Major Honors | FIFA World Cup (2018), Europa League (2017), Serie A Titles |
External Backlink
For more insights on Manchester United’s transfer strategies, check out this detailed analysis.